Private Investigator Home Page
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR
PRE-EMPLOYMENT
City: 0207 158 0332
Office: 01483 200999

www.answers.uk.com
Send Email Private Investigator Brochure

Pre-Employment Medical Questionnaires

The following article is reproduced with kind permission of Gemma Herrick of Brachers Solicitors and succintly discusses the legal implications of pre-employment medical questionnaires
Gemma Herrick

HR & Employment The following article is reproduced with kind permission of Gemma Herrick of Brachers Solicitors and succintly discusses the legal implications of pre-employment medical questionnaires.

Employment HR investigation

How much do applicants have to say? The High Court has recently held that an employee did not make misrepresentations when failing to mention a history of stress and depression in a pre-medical questionnaire. Ms Laird had been on anti-depressants during three episodes of stress related depression between 1997 and 2001 and remained on them until February 2002. In November 2001 Cheltenham Borough Council offered her the position of managing director 'conditional on medical clearance'. The employee did not mention depression or a history of stress and said she had enjoyed good health. She was passed fit for the job and started in February 2002.

Medical Questionnaire Shortly after this she was suspended from work and subject to investigatory proceedings. A psychiatrist reported Ms Laird unfit to undergo the investigation due to mental health problems. Ms Laird then retired on an ill-health pension. The council commenced proceedings against the employee alleging negligent and fraudulent misrepresentation in completing the medical questionnaire. The High Court rejected the council's argument on the basis that , while the offer had been conditional on completion of the council's questionnaire, the employee's answers had not been untrue and were therefore not misrepresentations.
Employment HR investigation There was a detailed analysis of the way that the council's questions had been posed and the nature of Ms Laird's illness, concluding that a reasonable person with episodes of depression would consider themselves normally to have good health. The moral of the case for employers is that if they want to elicit precise and clear answers, they should ask direct and specific questions. The more open and vague the questions, the easier it will be for emplyees to mask adverse medical history in a general answer.
Employment and HR Private Detective This specific questionnaire had no 'sweep-up' question either, such as "is there any aspect of your medical history which might affect an employer's decision to offer you employment?" Such questions should, of course, be carefully considered before being asked, since they may leave an employer vulnerable to a claim for disability discrimination.
Gemma Herrick Brachers

Gemma Herrick is an Employment Solicitor with Brachers Solicitors. Gemma did the second seat of her training contract in the Employment and HR Team at Brachers and returned in the final stages of her training, qualifying into the team in September 2009.  Gemma advises on a broad range of employment and HR issues working particularly closely with local businesses.  She also represents companies and individuals in Tribunal claims as well as advising on compromise agreements.


Private Detective Business Investigation Guildford Surrey Corporate InvestigationPrivate Investigation Infidelity Matrimonial Guildford SurreyProcess server Guildford Surrey Private InvestigatorPrivate detective office private investigator Guildford Surrey
Site Map
Area Office
Telephone
Email
Satellite offices
Guildford Private Detective Investigator
01483 200999
Alton Private Detective
Dorking Private Investigator
Haslemere Private Investigation
01420 409275
01306 519275
01428 769275
London Private Detective
0207 158 0332
South London Private Investigator
Weybridge Private Detective Call 01932 690337
Private Investigation in Watford
0208 479 3384
01932 690337
01923 428475
Reading Private Detective Call 0118 9733 049
0118 9733 049
Newbury Private Investigator Call 01635 818830
Private Investigation in Bracknell Call 01344 609466
Henley Private Eye Call 01491 699193
01635 818830
01344 609466
01491 699193
Southampton Private Detective Call 02380 308274
02380 308274
Andover Private Investigator Call 01264 839275
Romsey Private Investigation Call 01794 899274
Winchester Private Eye Call 01962 708185
01264 839275
01794 899274
01962 708185
Crawley Private Detective Call 01293 308475
01293 769475
East Grinstead Private Investigator Call 01342 349275
Private Investigation Chichester Call 01243 629093
Worthing Private Eye Call 01903 841178
01342 349275
01243 629093
01903 841178
Aldershot Private Detective Call 01252 308475
01252 308475
Reigate Private Investigator Call 01737 731475
Private Investigation Basingstoke Call 01256 689475
Camberley Private Investigator
01737 731475
01256 689475
01276 805275
Bournemouth private Investigator
01202 366156
Private Investigator New Forest Call 01590 690049
Salisbury
01590 690049
01722 398275
High Wycombe Private Investigator
01494 619397
highwycombe@answers.uk.com
Aylesbury Private Investigator
Thame Private Investigator
01296 509270
01844 259099
Tel: 0800 980 4 267

"searching the world for answers"

© F.L.I.P. Ltd 2002-2011

Email